Do you know those Holistic Writings you have to take in your English or Language Arts classes? You’re given a prompt, and you have 45 minutes to state your opinion on the subject. It could be anything from using animals in drug tests to having the school issue uniforms. They’re usually persuasive essays or speculative writings. If you do, I have something to share/question. This year, my school has decided to switch these holistic writings from paper onto computers using a site called MyAccess.
On one side, I’m really happy with this change. I HATE writing, and typing is so much faster, plus it’s way easier to edit. However, not all aspects of this are great. For one thing, many of the students in my school are affected by this change because they can’t type very fast. I remember last year in my English class our teacher gave us 2-3 entire periods devoted to typing up our handwritten story. I finished mine in about 15 minutes, then went on to type for 5-6 other kids who were obnoxiously slow. I know one of my friends hates this change, and her score was affected because of it.
The scoring rubric is also an issue. The program that grades the writings very interesting. Thousands and thousands of writings by students were submitted into the program with scores already given by living, breathing people. The program then picks out everything that had similar qualities in a score 6 paper, or a score 3 paper (Rubric goes from 1-6) and uses that information to grade your own paper. For my first essay, I got a 6/6, which is near impossible when getting graded by people. Of course, the subject matter was easy (lobbying for a laptop), but it still raises the question “Are these grades inaccurate?” On my second essay, I found that that was not the case. This time, we had to do something on Animal Testing, and if it should be banned. I got a 5.1/6, which is good, but not great. However, I also found that the computer will take off points for some things that it deems incorrect. For example, some words that are not recognized words, but perhaps proper nouns, are deemed spelling mistakes. Since it deems them mistakes, I find myself editing my writing style to fit the program’s needs. I know that on my first essay, I had to change the word “online” to “on-line.”
This change is interesting, but I’m not sure about ‘ideal.’ It’d be perfect if we were allowed the ability to type OR write the essays, then have actual people grade them. Not completely fair, seeing as the typing version gives the option to spellcheck, etc. So, does your school let you type essays, or is it just mine? Or have you had the ability for a long time? Let me know.
As a side note, the security on MyAccess isn’t what you call…secure…at all. If I knew my friend’s ID number, which is public knowledge, I could log in as him/her, and delete their writing, making it impossible for them to revise later on.